FabDigit

Benchmark · 4 materials

Steel Ductile Iron vs Steel Gray Iron vs Steel 1006 vs Steel 1008

Side-by-side benchmark of 4 steel grades.

Properties

PropertyDuctile IronGray Iron10061008
Yield strengthMPaksi275 MPa40 ksi140 MPa20 ksi165 MPa24 ksi170 MPa25 ksi
Tensile strengthMPaksi415 MPa60 ksi215 MPa31 ksi300 MPa44 ksi305 MPa44 ksi
Specific strengthMPa·cm³/g39202122
Densityg/cm³lb/in³7.1 g/cm³0.257 lb/in³7.15 g/cm³0.258 lb/in³7.87 g/cm³0.284 lb/in³7.87 g/cm³0.284 lb/in³
Hardness (HB equiv.)HB200 HB180 HB86 HB86 HB
Max service temp°C°F400 °C752 °F400 °C752 °F400 °C752 °F400 °C752 °F
Min service temp°C°F-20 °C-4 °F-20 °C-4 °F-20 °C-4 °F-20 °C-4 °F
Electrical conductivity% IACS3.1 % IACS1.8 MS/m2.6 % IACS1.5 MS/m12 % IACS7 MS/m11 % IACS6.4 MS/m
Machinability/100Very good75 / 100Excellent85 / 100Fair50 / 100Fair50 / 100
Weldability/100Poor25 / 100Not recommended10 / 100Excellent100 / 100Excellent100 / 100
Formability/100Not recommended10 / 100Not recommended1 / 100Excellent95 / 100Excellent95 / 100
Relative cost$$ Standard$$ Standard$ Budget$ Budget
ProcessesCNC, Cast/ForgeCNC, Cast/ForgeSheetSheet

Where each grade sits

One track per property; coloured markers are the compared grades, the shaded band is the steel family 10th–90th percentile and the tick its median.

Yield strength275 MPa40 ksi
250 MPa36 ksifamily median 540 MPa78 ksi1,270 MPa184 ksi
Tensile strength415 MPa60 ksi
420 MPa61 ksifamily median 800 MPa116 ksi1,750 MPa254 ksi
Density7.1 g/cm³0.257 lb/in³
7.8 g/cm³0.282 lb/in³family median 7.85 g/cm³0.284 lb/in³7.85 g/cm³0.284 lb/in³
Hardness (HB equiv.)200 HB
134 HBfamily median 210 HB558 HB
Max service temp400 °C752 °F
200 °C392 °Ffamily median 400 °C752 °F540 °C1,004 °F
Electrical conductivity3.1 % IACS
5.7 % IACSfamily median 9.7 % IACS12 % IACS
Machinability75 / 100
29 / 100family median 75 / 10075 / 100
Relative cost25
14family median 2553

Ductile IronGray Iron10061008

Strength versus weight

2005001,0002,0007.588.5Density (g/cm³)Yield strength (MPa) — log scale10061008Ductile IronGray Iron

Manufacturing and finishing

CapabilityDuctile IronGray Iron10061008
CNC machiningYesYes
Casting & forgingYesYes
Sheet metalYesYes
Default conditionAs CastAs CastHRHR
Min. machined wall0.8 mm0.8 mm
Best machined surfaceRa 1.6 µmRa 1.6 µm
Heat treatmentsQuench & Temper, Full Anneal, Stress ReliefQuench & Temper, Full Anneal, Stress ReliefQuench & Temper, Full Anneal, Stress ReliefQuench & Temper, Full Anneal, Stress Relief
AlCrNYesYesYesYes
AlTiNYesYesYesYes
Black OxideYesYesYesYes
CVD Al2O3YesYesYesYes
CVD TiCNYesYesYesYes
CVD TiNYesYesYesYes
CerakoteYesYesYesYes
Chemical EtchingYesYesYesYes
Chrome PlatingYesYesYesYes
Copper PlatingYesYesYesYes
CrNYesYesYesYes
DLCYesYesYesYes
Dot Peen MarkingYesYesYesYes
E-CoatingYesYesYesYes
Electro-chemical EtchingYesYesYesYes
Electroless Nickel (EN)YesYesYesYes
Embossing / DebossingYesYes
Epoxy CoatingYesYesYesYes

Showing 18 of 47 finishes — the full list is on each grade's datasheet.

Typical handbook values for the default condition, normalised for comparison. Hardness on non-Brinell scales is converted approximately for charting only. Request certified data with your order for design-critical properties.